Engineering plastic phase transitions via solid solutions: the case of “reordering frustration” in ionic plastic crystals of hydroxyquinuclidinium salts

A family of salts of R-(+)-(3)-hydroxyquinuclidinium [QH]+, with SO42−, BPh4−, BF4− and PF6− counter-anions, have been prepared by the metathesis of [QH]Cl and metal salts of the corresponding anions. Solid solutions of formula [QH](PF6)x(BF4)1−x for x = 0.9, 0.8, 0.7 have also been obtained. The crystalline materials have been investigated by a combination of solid-state techniques, including variable temperature XRD, thermal analyses, multinuclear (11B, 13C, 15N, 19F, and 31P) solid-state NMR spectroscopy, variable temperature wideline 19F T1 relaxation measurements, and micro-Raman spectroscopy to investigate their thermal stability and phase transition behaviors. It has been shown that the salts [QH]PF6 and [QH]BF4 undergo an order–disorder solid–solid phase transition to plastic phases, whereas [QH]2SO4·H2O and [QH]BPh4 do not display any plastic phase transition. Doping [QH]BF4 into the [QH]PF6 lattice up to 30% results in the formation of a solid solution that is plastic in an expanded thermal range, thanks to a phenomenon that we describe here for the first time as “reordering frustration”.