Improving the precision of forces in real-space pseudopotential density functional theory

The high-order finite difference real-space pseudopotential density functional theory (DFT) approach is a valuable method for large-scale, massively parallel DFT calculations. A significant challenge in the approach is the oscillating “egg-box” error introduced by aliasing associated with a coarse grid spacing. To address this issue while minimizing computational cost, we developed a finite difference interpolation (FDI) scheme [Roller et al., J. Chem. Theory Comput. 19, 3889 (2023)] as a means of exploiting the high resolution of the pseudopotential to reduce egg-box effects systematically. Here, we show an implementation of this method in the PARSEC code and examine the practical utility of the combination of FDI with additional methods for improving force precision and/or reducing its computational cost, including orbital-based forces, compensating charges (namely, adding and subtracting a judiciously chosen charge density such that the total density is unaltered), and a modified spatial domain in which the real-space grid is defined. Using selected small molecules, as well as metallic Li, as test cases, we show that a combination of all four aspects leads to a significant reduction in computational cost while retaining a high level of precision that supports accurate structures and vibrational spectra, as well as stable and accurate molecular dynamics runs.